In my review of Doughnut Economics I mentioned that it was the highest density of pull-quotes I’d pulled from a single book. It’s fitting, then, that it’s the first book I wanted to reference in talking about Abundance, which has now taken that crown.1 I wanted to compare because Abundance directly addresses the degrowth movement. It’s a very solid argument—degrowth sounds nice on paper, but good luck getting people to actually vote for it—that I find hard to counter. And I find it hard to want to; I am, indeed, one of those voters who, now that you point it out, enjoys my quality of life and am at least somewhat loathe to give it up.
Abundance, the political concept, is much more invigorating. It’s an easy sell: forget limiting ourselves, we can build and invent our way out of this problem like we’ve built and invented our way out of previous problems. We can have our cake and eat it too; that’s how owning a food works!2
Nothing in the book felt hugely novel to me, although that may be because a huge portion of the “here’s why government in the US is bad at doing stuff right now” is a condensed version of Why Nothing Works, another recent read.3 I think what made me enjoy this book so much was in how well it pulled together many concepts that had already made their way into my head. There’s value to an effective condensation of information; more people will spend a few hours reading this book than will spend hundreds doing the mix of reading articles, poring through books, and watching Urbanist YouTube that put me at this “I already knew most of this” point.
So, even more than I do with most of my book reviews, I’d urge you to read this one. It’s not a long read—it took me a while, but that’s because I was copying so much of it into my notebook; let yourself use the highlighting feature in your e-reader, and you’ll get through it quicker than I did. It was well worth the time, though; check it out.4
- I think, anyways – I can’t be bothered to find the memo book I took those notes in, but I did fill roughly half of a Field Notes with this book alone. ↩
- No, but seriously, what a weird bit of phrasing that is. ↩
- I specify “in the US” because, after rattling off all the statistics about how the US gets less bang for more buck on public infrastructure projects, the authors dropped this amazing line: “We looked into it, and it turns out that all those countries also have governments. So the problem cannot simply be government.” (Chapter 2) ↩
- This is a Bookshop affiliate link – if you buy it from here, I get a little bit of commission. It won’t hurt my feelings if you buy it elsewhere; honestly, I’d rather you check it out from your local library, or go to a local book store. I use Bookshop affiliate links instead of Amazon because they distribute a significant chunk of their profits to small, local book stores. ↩




